The Steubenville 2 Convicted

Last August 2012 in Steubenville, Ohio, a 16-year-old West Virginia girl was kidnapped and raped by two high school football players. The girl was inebriated and unconscious; the boys – Trent Mays and Ma’lik Richmond – took the girl from party to party, Instagram’d, Tweeted, and texted pictures of them assaulting her. There was even a YouTube video of a former Steubenville football player joking about what had happened to her.

This is unthinkable and I can’t imagine the trauma the victim has lived through since August. What’s even worse is the overwhelming support that Mays and Richmond have received from the community. Their parents, their football coaches, even the police have aided them and contributed to America’s increasingly prevalent rape culture and slut-shaming.

As the case has received national attention, hacker group Anonymous released private information on many of the football players and community members involved in the case, alleging that even more people should be prosecuted for enabling and protecting the rapists.

While many from the Steubenville community seem to support the rapists based on the old saying “boys will be boys” and their high-profile status of being star high school athletes, many advocates on the internet have spoke out against this injustice.

Michael Kimmel of Ms. Magazine blames all 18,437 Steubenville residents for the crime saying that this incident is not surprise given the “athletic privilege” that star athletes receive in their communities. Kimmel, a sociologist, is the author of Guylandwhich is based on 400 interviews of men ages 16-26 regarding “Guy Code” (i.e. “locker room behaviors, sexual conquests, bullying, violence, etc.). Kimmel suggests that allowing the “boys will be boys” stereotype to prevail in our society assumes that boys can be nothing more than “wild rapacious animals.” We must expect more than this from men, we must acknowledge that men are more than just rapists and must be raised to respect people – especially women – by honoring their right to say “no” to sex. And certainly, a girl who is unconscious and unable to speak for herself is not consenting to being drug around from party to party, sexually assaulted, and video recorded for the entire Internet to see.

Thankfully, on March 17, 2013, the juvenile court ruled for Mays and Richmond to spend at least a year in juvenile detention and to register as sex offenders. Attorney General Mike DeWine hopes that in mid-April more charges will be made possibly against other teens, parents, school officials, and football coaches. While the sentences for Mays and Richmond seem minimal to me and other advocates in the social media, CNN caused a stir yesterday during their report of the trial. Corespondent Poppy Harlow, news anchor Candy Crowley, and legal expert Paul Callan all described how “emotional” it was to see the two rapists convicted focusing on their “youth” and “vulnerability.”

Here are some excerpts:

Poppy Harlow to Candy Crowley

“Incredibly difficult, even for an outsider like me, to watch what happened as these two young men that had such promising futures, star football players, very good students, literally watched as they believed their lives fell apart…when that sentence came down, [Ma’lik] collapsed in the arms of his attorney…He said to him, ‘My life is over. No one is going to want me now.’ Very serious crime here, both found guilty of raping the sixteen-year-old girl at a series of parties back in August.”

Paul Callan

“Sixteen-year-olds just sobbing in court, regardless of what big football players they are, they still sound like sixteen-year-olds…what’s the lasting effect, though, on two young men being found guilty in juvenile court of rape, essentially?”

“The most severe thing with these young men is being labeled as registered sex offenders. That label is now placed on them by Ohio law…That will haunt them for the rest of their lives. Employers, when looking up their background, will see that they’re registered sex offenders. When they move into a new neighborhood and somebody goes on the Internet, where these things are posted, neighbors will know that they are registered sex offenders.”

Social media advocates were quick to point out that Mays and Richmond made a CHOICE to kidnap and rape the victim, and they are simply being punished for their actions. However, the victim’s life was destroyed back in August and she is continually being re-victimized and shamed for what happened.

Mallory Ortberg of Gawker commented:

For readers interested in learning more about how not to be labeled as registered sex offenders, a good first step is not to rape unconscious women, no matter how good your grades are.

For those that are infuriated as I am by how CNN and other rapist-sympathizers are treating this case, I would suggest visiting UniteWomen’s Facebook as they are doing a wonderful job at tracking the progress of the Steubenville case and advocating on behalf of survivors of rape. Check out this letter to Jane Doe of Steubenville.

A petition was recently filed with demanding that CNN apologize for their coverage of the trial. Please sign and share the petition, here.

So readers, what do you think about this case? Were Mays and Richmond’s sentences long and harsh enough? How could CNN have covered the trial better? What can we, as a society, do to reduce the prevalence of rape? How does “athletic privilege” play a role in this case? Are young male athletes too entitled in our country?

Feel free to share your thoughts!

PS: I plan on reading Guyland by Dr. Michael Kimmel soon, and will be discussing it soon!

UPDATE: Since I posted this entry, Fox News has topped CNN by neglecting to redact the victim’s name from their latest coverage of the Steubenville case. ThinkProgress also notes at the bottom of the article that MSNBC also ran a clip of the girl’s name on Sunday. Great. This is turning into one giant media fail at the victim’s expense. Sounds like our top news stations need a lesson on respect.

5 responses to “The Steubenville 2 Convicted

  1. Thank you for covering this. I speak most of yesterday incensed over this issue and the CNN coverage of it. When will someone cover the victim and the devastation of her life? Our society has a long way to go when it comes to our approach to rape victims and perpetrators.

  2. I’m glad that this trial is coming to an end as I hope that the fighting can end, and hopefully both the survivor and the community can work towards healing.

    I read a response this morning that articulated my feelings on the final outcomes of this long, horrible set of events. It was written by Mia McKenzie, a Black feminist and queer who asks us to think about where the conviction will leave us in several years.

    “The fact is that once these boys enter the prison system, even ​in juvenile detention, chances are that they will return to it. It will, with little doubt, fuck them up more than they are already fucked-up. They will not likely emerge from prison as two well-adjusted men who respect women and understand that sexual assault against them is not okay. That’s not what prison does for people.”

    Its from

  3. It’s so horrible to hear what this girl survived through.The abominable reaction from the town is so telling of a culture steeped in rape and objectivity of women , it makes me embarrassed to share a country with those people…

    I look forward to hearing about Guyland, I think I read an small excerpt from that book for a women’s studies class and really enjoyed the perspective…can’t wait to hear more! You did an excellent job thoughtfully portraying this issue and its impact- well done.

  4. This is the main reason that so many rapes go unreported in our society. The victim gets revictimized on a daily basis, has little support, has to deal with the rest of her life as that girl that ruined the boy’s life.
    The fact that the guys, who are now convicted rapists, are the ones receiving the sympathy is horrendous. Yes, their lives are going to be much more difficult now, but that is because they decided to hurt someone else. If they had killed her the community would not be as sympathetic, but because she was passed out and they raped her, that’s ok?
    The boys will be boys attitude needs to end. All it does it excuse behavior that is inappropriate, teaching them that it’s ok to be inappropriate as adults. Our society needs to learn that it is important to treat everyone with respect, unfortunately the trend appears in the opposite direction.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s